Man sitting with laptop

The
Red Evolution
Blog

Plain english musings, guides and news from people at the coalface of digital marketing.

  • Blog
  • Why Do Website Quotes Vary So Much? £6k vs £60k Explained

You sent the same brief to three or four agencies, and the quotes came back at £6,000, £18,000, £25,000 and £60,000. If you're the FD or MD who has to sign one of them off, that spread is hard to make sense of, and the natural reaction is to assume someone is trying it on.

Sometimes they are, but more often than not the quotes are all reasonable prices for different projects. Every agency has read the brief, filled in the gaps it leaves with their own assumptions, and priced what they imagined, so the work in this post is mostly about finding those assumptions and making the quotes comparable before you pick one.

A quick disclosure before we start: we're one of the agencies that sends these quotes, and we're rarely the cheapest, so read this with that in mind. It's the guide we'd want a client to read before comparing us with anyone else, and some of it applies to us as much as anyone.

But before we get into the weeds, here's where we are with bunging an RFP out to multiple agencies and hoping for the best. In a recent conversation, it came to light that a potential customer found 20 agencies, 'narrowed it down' to 10 and sent them an RFP.

This will only achieve one outcome: confusion.

A better plan is to get to know 2 or 3 agencies and invite only those to provide a proposal. For us, "we've sent this to 10 agencies" is a massive red flag and a definite "thanks, but no thanks" response. And most decent agencies would be the same.

You didn't send the same brief; you just think you did

Most website briefs run to two or three pages, although a recent one we received was 32 pages, and they describe what the business does, what's wrong with the current site and roughly what the new one should achieve. What they almost never say is who writes the words, who supplies the photography, how many different page layouts are needed, what happens to the pages that already rank in Google, or whether the enquiry form needs to talk to the CRM.

Each agency fills those gaps differently. The £6k quote has usually assumed you'll hand over finished copy and images, that a ready-made theme will do, and that the old site can simply be switched off. The £60k quote has probably assumed the agency will write everything, shoot new photography at your works, build a bespoke design, migrate and redirect every old URL, and connect the site to your CRM. Both can be fair prices for the work each agency assumed it was quoting for.

So before asking why one quote is ten times the other, write down, line by line, what each one includes and what it leaves to you. Your favourite AI tool will do that for you.

As a case in point, recently, we received a detailed brief with a £20k budget. We extracted all the deliverables and provided low, high and median prices for each. Using an industry benchmark rate, circa £100/hr, the low estimate came in at just under £60k.

Where the money in a website quote actually goes

When you break a quote down, the cost of a B2B website sits in a handful of places, and the big swings between agencies almost always come from the same four or five.

Design, and how much of it is bespoke

Design cost is driven by the number of unique page templates, not the number of pages. A 40-page site built on six templates can cost less to design than a 12-page site where every page is different. In our own pricing, design for a B2B site typically sits between £5,000 and £15,000, and our guide to what a good B2B website costs breaks that down in more detail. A quote built on a bought theme skips most of this line, which is fine if a standard look suits you.

Content, which is where most cheap quotes quietly step back

This is the biggest single difference we see between quotes, and the one that causes the most grief. Writing clear, technically accurate copy for an engineering or manufacturing business takes interviews with your engineers, drafts, reviews and rewrites, and for a decent-sized site that's weeks of work. If the quote says "client to supply content", that work is still happening; it's just moved onto your desk, and in our experience it's the most common reason website projects stall.

Platform and licences

An open source platform like WordPress or Joomla has no licence fee, while HubSpot's CMS starts at around £350 a month for the Professional tier, so two quotes with similar build fees can have very different running costs. The better choice depends on what else you need the site to do, and we've written separately about how to choose between HubSpot and WordPress if that's the question in front of you.

Integrations and functionality

A quote calculator or product configurator typically adds £1,000 to £2,000, and a live connection to a third-party database or ERP can add £3,000 to £5,000. Some quotes include these as line items, some bury them in a total, and some leave them out on the assumption you'll ask later.

Discovery, migration and project management

These lines are easy to mistake for padding. Discovery is the work of understanding your buyers and what they need from the site before anyone designs anything. Migration maps every old URL to its new home so the rankings and links you've built over years carry over, and project management is the time someone spends making sure the thing actually gets finished. The cheapest quotes tend to leave all three out.

Where the cheap quote ends up costing more

None of this means a £6k website is always a bad buy. For a small firm that already has its copy written, doesn't rely on search for enquiries and needs something presentable to send people to, it can be exactly the right answer.

The trouble starts when a business that wins work through its website buys a quote that was priced for one that doesn't. The costs that show up later are fairly predictable. There's the content you end up writing yourselves, usually in the evenings, months after the planned launch date. There's the search traffic you lose when old pages are switched off without redirects, which can take a long time to win back. Then there are the paid plugins with annual renewals nobody mentioned, the change requests charged at an hourly rate because the original scope was so thin, and the second rebuild two or three years later when the site can't do what the business needs.

Our rule of thumb is that a B2B website under around £10,000 probably won't generate many enquiries on its own. It might look fine, but there usually isn't enough budget for the content, structure, and search work that generates leads.

When the expensive quote is padding

A high quote isn’t automatically the better one either. Some of the gap between a £25k quote and a £60k quote is real work the cheaper agencies have left out, but some of it can come from overheads.

A high quote can come from overheads (a big agency with account managers, strategists, and a nice office has to pay for all of them), from layers of meetings and sign-offs the project doesn't need, or from risk pricing. Agencies don't tend to mention that last one, but it's common: when an agency doesn't fully understand part of a brief, or doesn't fancy the work, it often adds a healthy margin to cover itself. If one quote is far above the others, ask which parts they consider risky and why, because the answer will tell you a lot about whether it's padding or something the others have missed.

How to compare website quotes properly

The simplest fix is to stop comparing totals. Take the most detailed quote you've received, list every line item, again, AI will do this in a heartbeat, and send that list back to the other agencies, asking them to say what's included, what's excluded, and what each excluded item would cost. You'll often find the gap between quotes shrinks a lot once they're pricing the same thing, and you'll also quickly learn which agencies are happy to be transparent about their pricing and which aren't.

Then look at the cost over three years. Add up the build fee, platform licences, hosting, support and any paid plugins over 36 months. A £6k build that has to be replaced in year three, with the copy you paid someone else to write along the way, can easily cost more over that period than a £25k build that's still doing its job in year six. Our website costs explained page sets out what we charge for support and management if you want a reference point.

Finally, check what each agency thinks the website is for. If the brief is about generating enquiries and one of the proposals barely mentions search, content or how buyers find you, that's worth weighing alongside the price. Our guide on how to build a lead generation website covers what should be in a site that's meant to bring in work, and it's a useful yardstick to hold the proposals against.

Questions to ask every agency before you sign

These are the questions we'd ask if we were sitting on your side of the table, and any agency worth hiring should be able to answer them without fuss:

  • Who writes the content, who supplies the images, and how many rounds of revisions are included? The revisions bit can be tricky.
  • How many unique page templates is the design based on, and is it bespoke or built on a bought theme?
  • What happens to our existing pages and their search rankings, and is redirect mapping included?
  • Which platform are you proposing, what are the licence and hosting costs each year, and who owns the site and its content if we part company?
  • Which plugins or third-party tools are paid for, and who pays the renewals?
  • Does the site connect to our CRM, and what happens to an enquiry once someone hits submit?
  • Which parts of this quote are fixed and which are estimates?
  • What does support cost after launch, and what does it cover?

If an agency gets defensive about any of these, that's useful to know before you sign rather than after. It's also worth reading our piece on why client and agency relationships fail, because many of those failures start with a quote both sides understood differently.

If you've got quotes on the table and would like a second pair of eyes, we're happy to go through them with you, including telling you whether the cheaper one looks like the right call. You can see how we approach website design and development, or just drop us a line.

Get In Touch

Frequently asked questions

Why do website quotes vary so much for the same brief?

Because most briefs leave out the details that drive cost, such as who writes the content, how much of the design is bespoke, whether existing pages and rankings are migrated, and which systems the site connects to. Each agency fills those gaps with its own assumptions and prices a different project, so the first step is to list what each quote includes and excludes before comparing totals.

Is the cheapest website quote ever the right choice?

Yes, when the business already has its content written, doesn't rely on the website or search to win enquiries, and needs a simple, presentable site. It becomes a false economy when a business that wins work online buys a site priced without content, migration or search work, because those costs come back later as lost rankings, delays and an early rebuild.

How much should a B2B website cost in the UK?

In our experience a lead-generating B2B website usually starts at around £10,000, and design alone typically sits between £5,000 and £15,000 depending on the number of unique templates.  How far above that a quote goes depends mostly on how much content, integration and migration work is included, which is why it’s worth comparing quotes line by line.

How do I compare website quotes fairly?

Take the most detailed quote, turn it into a list of line items, and ask every agency to price against that same list and say what's excluded. Then compare the total cost over three years, including licences, hosting, support and paid plugins, as well as the build fee, because licences, support and an early rebuild can change which option is cheaper.

Newsletter Subscription

Inbound Marketing News In Your Inbox

We find the information that matters so you don't have to